Hungry Man is a band I’m in and Eater is our first record. I recorded it almost a year ago (with Jon San Paolo’s assistance/tape op-ing) and mixed it a couple of weeks later. I’m not happy with how it sounds and want to put down in writing what I don’t like about it and what I should have done better. If you read this and are interested in listening to the record, you can hear it here.
I think it was recorded well, and frankly, a monkey can setup in Electrical Audio’s studio A and get usable results. The problem was mixing it. Here’s what I think I did wrong and what I’d do differently next time.
– We mixed loud. I didn’t have an SPL meter with me, but I think it was at the very least 85dB SPL loud. This was dumb for a couple of reasons. One is that our ears got fatigued fast and we took no breaks (mixing was done in a day) which made them even more tired. The second is that it was my second time working in that studio (not EA), so I didn’t really know how things sound there, and I think the room was interfering with what I was hearing. Also, when we mastered Bob Weston gave me this great advice – he said to mix at the volume the music will be listened to. With all that being said, the Fletcher-Munson curve says that our hearing flattens as things get louder, so maybe loud is better?
– The bass is too loud. I think that this goes back to monitoring too loud (although it contradicts what I said about the Fletcher-Munson curve), but also to the fact that I play bass and probably had the inclination to push it up. In the room it really didn’t sound that loud. If I were to mix it now, I’d drop the bass down by at least 2dB.
– The snare sounds wonky. This is probably my biggest mistake. The snare sounded beautiful when we recorded, it’s a 5.5 Supraphonc chrome over brass that has an explosive sound. However, sometimes it disappeared in the mix, so I set on fixing that by pushing some mid frequencies. I think I overdid it which made it actually lose some definition and sound wonky. A better idea would have been to compress it a tiny bit. That would have helped it stick out. FWIW, I got the mid frequencies advice from a fellow engineer who does amazing work, but I executed it wrong.
– The kick is.. weird. It’s very full and has this insane attack, but it’s too, I don’t know, pop-punk? What was going on was that I gated the beater side microphone to get rid of the snare there, and I mixed it too loud with the front side microphone. I think the fact that I consistently mixed it wrong with the front side mic is maybe a testament to how I wasn’t hearing things as they actually were.
– The drums disappear sometimes. I could have maybe gotten away with compressing the drums. Just a tiny bit so they don’t drown.
– The record is dark. Hear how dark it is? It was actually darker when we mixed it. I should have eq-ed the overheads and added ~1.5dB at around 10k. Maybe same thing with the room mics. Definitely should have added high end to the guitars and cut some of their low end. I think that part of the bass being loud is that we were competing over the same frequencies a little bit.
– There are room mics on the vocals, and I gated them so they open up when the singer yells. Thing is, the singer always kind of yells. It’s not like Heart Shaped Box by Nirvana where Kurt Cobain all of a sudden yells while the band maintains the same dynamics. Gating the room mics is a cool effect, but doesn’t work on every record or every song, and I should have known better.
– There was a room mic on the guitars that we ended up not using. I honestly don’t think there was room for guitar room here, but a big part of why we didn’t use the room mic is because it was unusable. It just sounded flimsy. Like someone accidentally left a microphone open, and it sounds bad and off-axis. What happened is that the guitars were in Center Field and they weren’t very loud. I mean, they were loud, but they weren’t absolutely filling the space with sound. The room mic was placed very far from the amps, maybe 25ft or more. It was dumb. Placing it closer I could have gotten something useful.
– We mixed 8 songs AND re-did vocals for a couple of songs in one day. And of course it’s not like we got in and started working. I had to calibrate the tape machines, set up microphones for singing (it’s quick, but still), then break them down, and only then start mixing. Also, I got in a car accident (wasn’t my fault) on the way to the studio, and while I was physically fine, it did cost me 30-45 minutes of dealing with it. I was also thrown off by the whole thing a bit.
To sum what I should have done differently in the mix: lower the bass, boost the high end on the drums, boost the high end on the guitars, don’t mix in so much of the beater side mic, don’t gate the room mics.
Also, next time I mix a record I think I’ll tell the band to get there half a day after me. This way I can listen to everything and take notes on what might need work, and be more prepared. Also, mixing 8 songs in one day is a bad idea. Two days of mixing would have made this so much easier, physically and mentally, and would have given me more time to get things to sound right.